Jean Chatzky
< Back

Ask Jean Thursday: Debt Distress

iStock_000010136948XSmallAs a distressed homeowner, should I try to modify my loan, or short sale my home?
-Eve, Florida

By distressed, I assume you mean unable to make your mortgage payments.  If you can pay your mortgage – even if your home is one of the one-third in this country that are underwater – then as long as you are not in a position where you have to sell, you can hold on and wait for property values to come back.  But if you can’t pay, you’re right to be exploring both of these options.

Let’s run through the pros and cons of each.

A loan modification is designed to keep you in your home.  A loan modification, in most cases, trims your monthly payments by lowering the interest rate.  Generally the new lower rate will last five years, which will hopefully be enough time to get back on your feet.  Although loan modifications were advertised not to impact credit scores, that’s not how they’re actually working.   Lenders are reporting to the credit bureaus that borrowers with modifications are making partial payments which is taking down scores 75 to 125 points.  (Foreclosures, on the other hand, reduce scores by two to three times that amount.)

Short sales, on the other hand, provide a way for you to sell a home that’s worth less than you owe on it.  If you are underwater in your loan and can’t make your payments, you may be able to arrange with the bank to sell it for less than you owe on the mortgage.  A lot of back and forth goes into this process, but if you are successful you can walk away from the home doing about the same amount of damage to your credit score as you would with a loan modification and start fresh.  And while in years past, you might have been charged income taxes on the amount of debt you were allowed to escape, right now that’s not an issue as long as the amount of debt forgiven is less than $2 million and the home is your principal residence.

So which is the lesser of two evils?  If after running the numbers on a loan modification, you believe you will be able to afford to make the payments at the modified rate, I’d pursue that option.  Yes, the wheels on loan mods have been moving very slowly, but over the last month a spate of bad press has kicked things up a bit.  Start with a phone call to your lender.   Speak to someone in the workout department.  And if you are having difficulty communicating, go to HUD.gov and speak to a housing counselor.  Ask the counselor to call your lender with you on the line and act as an intermediary.  Be patient.  And good luck.

Subscribe to my free weekly Newsletter

We collect, use and process your data according to our Privacy Policy.